UK time is: 18:09:36
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

RUFC - Is The 'Selection Rule' In The JPT Fair?

While Rotherham United get ready to take on Hartlepool United in the quarter finals of the Johnstone's Paint Trophy I got to wondering how fair the competition actually was.

Before the last round Swindon Town Manager Mark Cooper had a moan to the media about the selection rule in the competition with Preston North End Manager Simon Grayson also miffed by the rule.

The rule states that six players who started the previous game should also start the Johnstone's Paint Trophy tie - meaning that you can only make five changes for the game. We've seen teams get round this by starting with six of the previous players who played but then subbing three of them very early in the game.

When this rule was first introduced I presume it was thought it was for the good of the competition meaning that teams wouldn't put their 'young unused players' in but, on the other hand, you have a squad of players so why can't you use your full squad? And isn't it good for the players who probably wouldn't get many chances of first team games to play in this competition?

Our own Steve Evans has said that he will probably make as many changes as he is allowed on Tuesday night - although two are enforced changes as Kari Arnason and Michael O'Connor are away on International duty.

Let's be honest to a lot of clubs this competition means very little unless they get to the Wembley - to the fans as well - and I have to say I feel it's just a set of games that puts your best players in the 'shop window' while they can also get injured/booked/sent-off which won't help you in the league.

So, what do you think? Should the rules be revised and Manager's be able to play who they want? Or do you think the competition is fine just as it is?

Tell us here on Vital Rotherham
Join The Vital Debate






Vital Rotherham on: facebook

Vital Rotherham on: twitter




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: Herringthorpe  Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday November 11 2013

Time: 7:46AM

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Rotherham United Articles

RUFC - Millwall Tickets On Sale (Wednesday January 28 2015)

RUFC - Evans Hoping For Permanent Signings (Wednesday January 28 2015)

RUFC - Evans Pleased For Goal Scorers (Wednesday January 28 2015)

RUFC - Evans 'Newton Was Outstanding' (Wednesday January 28 2015)

RUFC - Evans 'Players Were Fantastic' (Wednesday January 28 2015)

Rampant Millers Get First Win Of 2015 (Tuesday January 27 2015)

Rotherham v Bolton - Team Line-Ups (Tuesday January 27 2015)

RUFC - Millers v Derby New Date (Tuesday January 27 2015)

Millers v Bolton Preview (Tuesday January 27 2015)

Archived Rotherham United Articles

List All Vital Rotherham Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. rybel_b 1301
2. herringthorpe 1149
3. sixpence 506
4. mos60 47
5. miller4life 30
6. Millie Miller 23
7. mvmiller 20
8. axholme 18
9. nogginthenog 15
10. sthelensmiller 8

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
17. Charlton 27 6 14 7 -10 32
18. Reading 27 8 7 12 -11 31
19. Brighton 27 6 11 10 -5 29
20. Rotherham 27 6 11 10 -10 29
21. Leeds Utd 26 6 8 12 -11 26
22. Millwall 27 5 9 13 -19 24
23. Wigan 27 4 9 14 -10 21

Breaking League News

Jarvis Winging In?
Cardiff : 28/01/2015 18:01:00
Another Defeat Against Derby?
Cardiff : 28/01/2015 17:53:00
Meet The Ref - Ipswich v Latics Charles Breakspear
Wigan : 28/01/2015 17:51:00
Kayal Permit Obtained
Brighton : 28/01/2015 17:42:00
I'll Always Give 110% - Best
Brighton : 28/01/2015 17:36:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Should FA Cup Replays Be Scrapped?
Suggested By:  
Yes 51%
No 28%
Not Sure 21%